Saturday, July 23, 2011
Government can't defend bias to incineration
Monday, March 28, 2011
Call for Plaid to stand up against Incinerator ambitions driving Waste Policy in Wales
WASTE - A BURNING ISSUE
Time for Plaid to stand up against Incinerator ambitions driving Waste Policy in Wales
Plaid’s 2010 election manifesto is clear – 80% recycling/composting by 2020 plus opposition to waste incinerators. So let’s see Plaid condemning WAG’s rotten targets and its subsidies for incinerators –the £9 million/yr for Prosiect 'Gwyrdd' means £30-40million/yr throughout Wales.
Reality of Poor recycling targets and drive to mega-incinerators
WAG’s bias to incineration - subsidising gate fees and promoting regional consortia for 'residual' waste - is stronger than in England or Scotland. Contrary to Jane Davidson’s ‘green’ claims, there are no ambitious recycling targets in Wales are not ambitious. Only 70% recycling, or 65% excluding incinerator ash, not the 80-90% judged feasible. 75% is already reached in Flanders etc. 70% by 2015 is practicable, but WAG defers it till 2025 !
The 5-county Prosiect 'Gwyrdd' is leading WAG's drive for privatisation of waste in Wales, with a projected value of £1.1 billion over 25 years. The 4 chosen companies to bid for 25-year PFI contract are Covanta/Brig y Cwm; Viridor/Cardiff; Waste Recycling Group Ltd/Barry; Veolia ES Aurora Ltd/Newport, all variants of incinerators pretending to be ‘energy’ plants. Two claim to be CHP, providing some heat as well as energy, but don't qualify as they will use little of the heat and hardly reach half the 60% energy efficiency set in Wales.
Their 'Design, Build, Finance and Operate' arrangement is a version of PFI, the disreputable Private Finance Initiative. Prosiect Gwyrdd’s Chair (Lib-Dem Cllr Stephens) claimed it’s only a PPP (private-public partnership) yet “financing for the Project will be predominantly, if not wholly, procured from private finance.”
WAG recruited Howel Jones from Partnerships UK – promoter of Blair-Brown’s PFIs – to cajole and bribe all Welsh councils into similar waste projects. Private companies taking over waste management in Wales was a ‘new’ Labour agenda.
Why oppose the incineration of household waste?
The principal purpose is ‘disposal’ and the 5 counties’ declared plan for 35% incineration means reduced efforts for recycling/composting
Far from helping to 'tackle climate change', burning more rubbish produces far more carbon emissions (eg. from oil-based plastics) than it saves through electricity generation. Cardiff proposes to ignore incinerator CO2 by calling it ‘industrial’, so maintaining ‘green’ pretensions
The ‘business case’ relied on exaggerating future quantities of waste. Waste PFIs need guaranteed amounts of waste per week and they assumed waste tonnages will grow over the years to offset increased recycling.
Poses health risks with toxic emissions and huge tonnages of hazardous ash sent to landfill – with special low rate of landfill tax.
WAG's policy claims to be technology-neutral, yet
# they require the 25-year contracts, Private Finance model, with an incinerator as “reference technology”.
# force authorities to choose mega-waste companies and squeeze out Welsh businesses
# it’s part of the privatisation agenda, that has proved highly costly.
The alternatives to incineration are cheaper, more flexible, quicker to implement and better for the environment. Rather than incinerating waste, the best option is to reduce residual waste to a minimum, through more intensive recycling and sorting. WAG’s own consultant’s report shows 80% recycling is more economic than the 70% they chose, as well as being more ‘sustainable’. Prof. Paul Connett, the leading exponent of the ‘zerowaste’ movement, on a recent visit, condemned WAG’s policy.
P Gwyrdd ignores risks
locked into a 25-year private finance contract, even more expensive since the credit crunch
incinerator ash will be classed as 'hazardous waste', with high costs of treatment or disposal
penalties will be attached to the huge amounts of CO2 emitted by incinerators.
We call on Plaid Cymru tob continue to oppose the use of waste incinerators, disguised as Energy-from-Waste (EfW) urgently demand a independent review of the value-for-money of private finance
demand disclosure of full information, over-riding excuses of commercial confidentiality
Call Plaid Cllrs in Cardiff and Caerphilly to account for supporting Prosiect 'Gwyrdd'
Expose the greenwash of incineration by WAG’s “Waste Awareness Wales”
Stick to 2010 Plaid’s Westminster Manifesto
“We will continue to oppose the use of waste incinerators and support binding targets for waste prevention. We support recycling targets of 80% of domestic waste by 2020 and the introduction of a higher landfill tax. We will campaign for changes in public procurement legislation so that Local Authorities can favour materials from recycled and local sources”.
2008: Conference further calls:
On the Assembly Government to work with all local authorities across Wales to promote a consistent and standardized approach to waste management which takes recognition of the fact that recovery of energy from waste is fullest through maximising recycling including that of plastics, and the separate collection and anaerobic digestion of food way genste; and that, by contrast, incineration is a bad solution, inefficient in energy generation, and damaging to the environment and climate change
South Wales WIN, http://southwaleswin.com/ affiliated to UK Without Incineration Network (WUKWIN)
email southwaleswin@gmail.com
Strangely the lib dems attack Plaid on supporting inconeration when they too support it and chair the joint committee. More here
Cllrs on P Gwyrdd Joint Committtee where tories CALL THE SHOTS!!
Strange bed fellows! 2 Plaid 2 lib Dems 6 Tories
http://www.caerphilly.gov.uk/prosiectgwyrdd/english/joint_committee.html
Lyn Ackerman Plaid Cymru Caerphilly
Colin Mann Plaid Cymru Caerphilly
Margaret Jones Lib Dems Cardiff
Mark Stephens Lib Dems Cardiff
Philip Murphy Tory Monmouthshire
S B Jones Tory Monmouthshire bryanjones@monmouthshire.gov.uk
William Routley Tory Newport
David Fouweather Tory Newport
Cllr Geoffrey A. Cox Tory Vale of Glamorgan
Gordon C. Kemp Tory Vale of Glamorgan
Campaigners urge Plaid Cymru to uphold election pledge on incinerators
CAMPAIGNERS today were due to urge Plaid Cymru to stick to its election promise to oppose massive waste incineration schemes in South Wales.
The South Wales WithoutŠIncinerationŠNetwork (WIN) is pressing AMs, councillors and activists not to abandon their 2010 pledge to oppose the Prosiect Gwyrdd programme, which has won support from the Welsh Assembly Government.
The £1.1bn project privately funded over 25 years could, says WIN, see multiple incinerators built in South Wales, while WAG’s target to recycle 70% of rubbish by 2023 falls short of a possible 80% to 90% recycled.
A spokesman, speaking as Plaid Cymru holds its conference at Cardiff’s Wales Millennium Centre, argued: “Plaid’s 2010 election manifesto is clear – 80% recycling and composting by 2020 and opposing the use of waste incinerators.
“It’s high time Plaid condemned WAG’s rotten targets with subsidies for incinerators.“Shoving more waste up a chimney and spewing toxic emissions into the air will undermine recycling, not increase it.”
WIN also insists incineration poses public health risks with toxic emissions and huge amounts of hazardous ash sent to landfill.
It wants Plaid to oppose all waste incinerators and demand an independent review of PFI projects such as Prosiect Gwyrdd with much fuller information about them.
Independent Caerphilly councillor Anne Blackman said: “We in Europe are being hoodwinked into paying millions in subsidy to process valuable waste that’s dealt with for free or paid for by the collectors in Canada and Africa.
“These plants could put deposits that are smaller than soot into the air that might affect more people than coal dust did in the mining industry.
“We need our public health and environmental professionals to examine incineration proposals and provide scientific and medical evidence about its effect on public health.
“We need to see the evidence and have a public debate – not just foist this onto our great-grandchildren for the next 25 years.”
A spokeswoman for Plaid Cymru said: “Plaid’s commitment is to overhauling planning policy so that decisions in relation to waste can be made close to the people and serve the needs of communities.
“Local people need to have a voice in that process.
“We are also committed to working with universities and industry to find new ways to deal with non-recyclable waste.
“Ultimately, of course, this is a decision for local authorities. Plaid’s sustainability spokesperson Leanne Wood recently reaffirmed Plaid’s opposition to incineration, and questioned the Environment Minister on the Welsh Government’s subsidy to Prosiect Gwyrdd in the Assembly chamber.”
WAG declined to comment given the forthcoming election.
Read More http://www.walesonline.co.uk/news/wales-news/2011/03/26/campaigners-urge-plaid-cymru-to-uphold-election-pledge-on-incinerators-91466-28405958/#ixzz1HshCYMjU
Thursday, September 23, 2010
How many more incinerators can they fit in Wales?
The Environment Agency says "Our view: there should be a clearer process in place for the siting of major infrastructure such as energy, so that environmental and climate change outcomes are maximised. For example, we are aware that the Regional Waste Groups have tried to facilitate a more strategic approach through developing the Regional Waste Plans but this was carried out in isolation of other critical infrastructure needs. This means that opportunities for energy from waste and combined heat and power have potentially been missed."
How many more incinerators can they fit in Wales?
Viridor type incinerators are NOT energy from waste
opting for incineration of waste under the pretext that they can make electricity from the process!
Can Jane Davidson justify an INCREASE incineration to 30%!!!
Wednesday, September 2, 2009
Welsh to burn 37% Scots vote against incinerators
Scottish Parliament vote against large-scale incineratorsincinerators now 'greened' to energy from waste!
The vote in the Scottish Parliament, carried because the Tories voted with the Greens and SNP.
Just one Lib-Dem supported, 6 Labour absentees.
If burning up to a quarter of Scotland's municipal waste is "a failure of the imagination" how much bigger a failure is the proposed Welsh strategy with burning up to 37% proposed !
It appears that the governing SNP had a change in mind when confronted with 25% in their Minister's plan.
*S3M-4348.1 Scottish Parliament: National Waste Strategy (11 Jun 2009)
Thursday, April 9, 2009
Take action 15 April
April 15 lunch time 1.30 City Hall lawn outside city hall.
more on this here - join us as the council's planning committee rules on proposals for a large waste incinerator in the city.
There has been fierce opposition to the planning application from Viridor waste management for a 350,000 tonne per year waste incinerator to be situated in Trident Park, near Splott. Cardiff Friends of the Earth has handed in objections from over 300 people and many others have also expressed their opposition.
The group has objected to the proposal on the grounds that the incinerator would burn waste which should be recycled or composted. They argue that incineration is not an efficient way of generating energy and that pollution from the site could be harmful to the health of local residents and could pollute important wildlife sites.
The objection says that household waste should be dealt with as near to where it was produced as possible, whereas an incinerator would take waste from across south east Wales, possibly much further.
Phil Ward, Waste Campaigner for Cardiff Friends of the Earth will be speaking on behalf of the group at the council meeting. He commented:
“The people of Cardiff do not want a massive incinerator at the heart of the city burning waste from across south Wales. We should all be taking radical steps to reduce the amount of waste we produce. Then we need to be recycling and composting all we can.
“Incineration is not a 'green' technology and there is no sense in driving huge amounts of waste around the country increasing congestion and pollution. Other, less damaging and more sustainable, technologies are available that could be implemented in each local area "Monday, March 23, 2009
Rodney Berman hot under the collar!
Leader Cardiff council
Yes Rodney
I would have thought that pointing out these NEW serious flaws, described below, would be appreciated and you would address these extremely serious points now that you are aware of them. Your officers have not brought these matters to your attention! You have not addressed these points as yet. Friends of the earth and the green party will continue to ask these very questions and deserve an answer. In addition we will be asking how the Environmental Assessment on the air quality affects of the incinerator was done.
I had hoped you might respond with an open mind.
There are HUGE serious flaws in project ‘green’ and the Viridor planning application in skipping due process. The Viridor site has not been a llocated for waste management purposes in the Development Plan. If allocated in the future LDP, it would be subject to stronger tests, potentially through the public examination process, and to a soundness test
How can you ignore the development plan?
best wishes
and still hoping for a reply
Thursday, December 4, 2008
WAG not happy funding incinerator
Prosiect Gwyrdd item was pretty short - about 5 minutes. The main action was before that and was a very long heated discussion about the proposed school closures and related loss of open space in East Cardiff, and involving a lot of shouting from some members of the public attending.
The Prosiect Gwyrdd OBC recommendations were passed, i.e. for the project to continue along the lines in the report
Margaret Jones presented :
- the OBC is an interim document
- the project is of such a scale that it will need to come back to the Exec and also go to full Council next year
- no decision taken on site or technology
- irritated at misrepresentation of the project inside the Council and elsewhere (i.e. "PG = incinerator"
- this was supported by all councillors present
- there were no questions about the content of the report
Wednesday, December 3, 2008
Cardiff Council steamroller dodgy proposal for incinerator through

The Cardiff report smacks of desperation and looks like an attempt to steamroller a dodgy proposal through as quickly as possible before anybody checks their maths. It may be easy for them to blame the assembly but wasn’t their original timeline to complete the Outline Business Plan by December 2007 and to put the advert in the OJEU by March 2008 [1] but they still say it isn’t finished yet and now won’t go into the OJEU until Mar 09. In which case isn’t it really the project team and their (£ 250,000 + to date) consultants who are to blame for the full year slippage to date? And if the project can slip a full year between the July 2007 Cardiff Council Executive meeting and now what are the realistic prospects for it being delivered on time and to budget in the longer term?
Obviously the final draft OBC raises a lot of questions. Why, for example, have they placed so much emphasis on landfill penalties (at £ 200/tonne [2]) in the letter to Jane D, and in the OBC, when all the authorities will meet the Landfill Directive Diversion targets through complying with the National recycling targets?
The growth rates are unrealistically high – and a quick check shows the total MSW has fallen again in each of the authorities. The argument they use (in Appendix 4b and not 2a as they incorrectly reference in para 2.3.2) is a silly one:
“there is concern with basing projections on the high negative growth seen over the last few years, at is not completely understood how this reduction has come about. It would be more prudent to base projections on a higher growth rate in early years”The ‘prudence’ together with the reduction of the recycling target by 5% means they are pitching for 35% of 575,000 tonnes - which they then add another 10% to, presumably for ‘prudence’ to justify 220,000 tpa.
Prosiect llwyd is not necessary to comply with European targets and adds only 1.2% [3] to recycling – and that is low grade post incineration steel which could be recovered with higher quality at a landfill with a magnet. It is therefore difficult to understand why it is considered so important to concentrate on this residual waste project at this stage as it seems to requires a rather perverse mentality to prioritise this rather than the the main event of meeting the recycling targets,
A more realistic assessment of the residual waste need would, in any case, be 30% of 500,000 tonnes ie 150,000 tonnes. The proposal is therefore probably 50% too big with profound impacts on the costs assessments. This is a shoddy way to play with £ 1 billion of our money.
Even the proposed option with ash recycling would still need landfill for 36,500 tonnes of rejects; 6,300 tonnes of hazardous APCD residues (table 4.4). They should also add the requirement for at least half the bottom ash to be landfilled as this is the level being achieved in Hampshire. If we can demonstrate that the bottom ash is hazardous then even more would be landfilled. Thus the total landfill requirement of the Project would be 42,800 + 16,650 = 59,450 tonnes. The reduction in landfill compared with do nothing thus reduces to c. 90,000 tonnes. These corrections would make a large difference to the cost assessments.
The WRATE assessment is typically awful, but as expected given the fundamental flaws and limitations of the model.
The report has far too much redacted information
[1] Cardiff Council (2007). EXECUTIVE BUSINESS MEETING: 5 JULY 2007 MUNICIPAL RESIDUAL WASTE TREATMENT REPORT OF CORPORATE DIRECTOR AGENDA ITEM: 8 PORTFOLIO: ENVIRONMENT & TRANSPORT Prosiect Gwyrdd procurement.
[2] I think it will be difficult in any case for Wales to maintain the threat of a £ 200 penalty given that the English financial penalty was reduced to £ 150 by Environment Minister Elliot Morley on 9 December 2004 “as part of a package of measures designed to ensure that local authorities have the flexibility to meet challenging targets for the diversion of biodegradable municipal waste from landfill without increasing pressure on council tax”. It follows that landfill will never reach £ 200/tonne when LATS penalties are set at £ 150 in England – authorities would simply pay the penalty or export the waste to English landfills where the LATS can be traded and the market price for landfill would be below £ 150.
[3] The 1.2% is for metal recovery. More worrying is the comment at: 4.4.16 “It has recently (although unofficially) been suggested by the Assembly Government that bottom ash recycling may count towards future recycling targets”. This could add another 5.2% they claim – this is wrong because only half the ash is likely to be recycled and it is, in any case, an approach that has recently been rejected in England.
Report to Cdf Exec on Thursday 4th
Municipal Residual Waste Treatment (Prosiect Gwyrdd) - Report (169k)
Municipal Residual Waste Treatment (Prosiect Gwyrdd) - Appendix 1 (2.87M)
�h Municipal Residual Waste Treatment (Prosiect Gwyrdd) - Appendix 2-5 (350k)
Note they have reduced the 70% recycling target to 65% and say the Eunomia report is still contested.
Will abandon Prosiect Gwyrdd if WAG does not guarantee funding by March.
Regional Waste Plans held up.
Extracts from the Report
. The review of 2002 National Waste Strategy has been delayed;
. The “Eunomia report” (September 2007) outlining the economic and
achievability assumptions was challenged and a further review of this
work has not produced a clear way forward;
. A review of Regional Waste Plans was completed; but a further
review is apparently planned to include relevant Planning Policies
under TAN 21;
Stakeholder Consultation
33. The principal focus of the Partnership thus far has been internal -
although the Project and individual authorities have engaged with
external stakeholders to an extent e.g. Friends of the Earth. The need for
comprehensive stakeholder/community group engagement is recognised
and similar considerations apply to neighbouring local authorities and other public bodies through established consultative mechanisms. A communications strategy will be the main vehicle for doing this and early outputs will include the establishment of a Prosiect Gwyrdd website which members are asked to approve as part of this report.
Procurement & Timetable
36. For the reasons explained above, this report does not seek authority for procurement to commence;
RECOMMENDATIONS
The Executive is recommended to:
(1) Approve the Final Draft Outline Business Case for submission to WAG based upon the affordability gap described in this report for a Residual Waste Treatment Solution predicated upon a technology neutral assumption.
(2) Agree that the Approved Outline Business Case will remain subject to three conditions:
(i) The Procurement being premised upon a) a publicly owned site
being made available to bidders and as such maintaining
discussions with the Welsh Assembly Government is necessary
until a public authority contractually commits to securing an option in the Project’s control and to note that this does not preclude a private owned site being brought forward by a bidder or b) the
Partnership and WAG become satisfied that adequate private sector competition is available;
(ii) The Welsh Assembly Government providing the Authorities
sufficient comfort that they will fund the Project to at least a
minimum level of funding over the life of the Project as per the Outline Base Case; and
(iii) The partner authorities also approving the Outline Business Case with the same conditions applying.
(3) Agree that if the three conditions in recommendation 2 above are not all
met by 31 March 2009, the approval of the OBC automatically lapses
and the Council will reconsider matters including alternative options
outside of the scope of Project Gwyrdd.
Saturday, May 10, 2008
Greenwash and lies - lobbying unacceptable
use of safe recycled plastics in food packagingThe European Commission has adopted a new regulation to ensure safety of food packaging made of recycled plastics. This new action sets the conditions under which the manufacturers of food contact materials can use recycled plastics.
Write to your MEP about lobbying..corporate self interest is so blatant that there is a need for this to be regulated and people must be aware what is going on!
EU lobbying transparency a step closer but still some way to go
On 25 March 2008, the transparency group Alter-EU has accused the Commission of relying too heavily on business and industry lobbyists when drawing up EU legislation. In reaction, the Commission has said it will publish a list of individual experts who sit on its advisory groups by the summer. But, a European Parliament committee would like the EU to go further and called for a mandatory register of the estimated 15-20,000 lobbyists.
http://www.epha.org/a/2976
Expert Group on ‘Coal combustion, clean and efficient coal technologies, CO2 capture’
The Commission should not be party to a pact with companies in the policy-making arena where corporate self-interest is so obvious. These are companies with a clear profit motivewhen it comes to defining the concept of ‘clean coal’and how it can be developed. This isa hugely controversial environmental and social issue. A truly objective and indeed allroundeffective Expert Group should comprise of a large portion of independent scientists,research institutions, national administrations and environmental groups. These actors,with companies fromthe sector would bemore likely to assess the real capabilities andlimits of the ‘clean coal alternative’as ameans of addressing global warming.The current composition of this Expert Group is not acceptable. The Commission shoulddissolve it and form a new one. The onus is on the Commission to informthe publicabout the role played by this group so far.70
[9]ECCP working group on the integrated approach to reduce CO2 fromlight duty vehicles
All info availlable at:http://circa.europa.eu/Public/irc/env/eccp_2/library?l=/light-duty_vehicles/
11]corporate controlled no (commission,member states, ACEA, KAMA, JAMA)Super-visory group of the voluntary commitments of car manufacturers to reduce CO2emissions
[23]coporate controlled Alternative fuels Based on the findings of this study the authorsmake the following recommendations to the European Commission.The European Commission ought to reform the mechanisms by which it accesses expertise. It should ensure such mechanisms are both transparent and operate fairly.For the latter to be the case, different points of viewmust be balanced against oneanother where impartial scientific advice is sought in an atmosphere immune fromcorporate capture. Taking the following steps in relation to the Expert Groups would bea long overduemove in this direction:
1.Disclosure of Expert Groupmembership and key documents;2.Full transparency around the launch of new Expert Groups;3.Open and fair processes around the application for and selection ofmembership;4.Strong safeguards against privileged access and unbalanced composition of these groups;5.Dissolution of all Expert Groups controlled by industry (or any other special interests);6.A broad review on the composition of all Expert Groups by the Commission’sSecretariat General
Thursday, January 31, 2008
Incinerator News from elsewhere

This week, I was one of three councillors from Restormel Borough Council who publicly re-stated calls for a Public Inquiry into the construction of a large waste to energy plant (incinerator) in Mid Cornwall. ...
A Suffolk County Councillor has said that proposed plans for the council to build an incinerator at Great Blakenham would waste the council money. ...
Years ago, someone had the brilliant idea to build a toxic waste incinerator located in a flood plain next to an elementary school. The project started during the administration of George Herbert Walker Bush but was continued by the ...
Daily Kos - http://www.dailykos.com/section/Diary
Tuesday, December 11, 2007
Incinerators can burn big holes in public purse!
Incinerator burns hole in public purse
Almost £2 million of taxpayers' money has been spent on legal fees for a controversial incinerator.
The Argus | General news - http://www.theargus.co.uk
Sustainable waste policy is possible
By Philip Booth(Philip Booth)
Over the last couple of months I have been working more on our waste policy - see draft earlier on this blog for 9th November with photos of a monster incinerator - we are getting closer to completion. Today I helped draft a letter that ...
Ruscombe Green - http://ruscombegreen.blogspot.com/
Tuesday, November 27, 2007
stop Wales being carpeted with incinerators
There was a fairly good chance of influencing the LAs until WAG announced their capital spending fund for partnership working on waste projects would only awarded to EfW plants, not MBT. This decision seems to have been taken after seeing the Hyder report they commissioned for the Regional Waste Plan consultations. This, in turn, seems to be based on the WRATE analysis they did of the options.
The WRATE analysis Hyder did was biased in favour of EfW, the WAG should reconsider their position and stop Wales being carpeted with incinerators.